An excerpt from Gary Lawrence’s forthcoming book “The Magnificent Gift of Agency; To Act and Not Be Acted Upon.”
Ever heard of Harmenszoon van Rijn?
A child of the early 1600s, he led a roller-coaster life – the whole gamut from spectacular success, wealth and fame to financial collapse, bankruptcy and poverty, and the deaths of three children. He mingled with royalty and the elite of his day, but also had a lifelong habit of studying beggars and the homeless. How could such a scope of emotions and observations of others not influence his creative process?
It did. The world knows him by one name only … Rembrandt.
Steps of Creativity
As with all progress in mortality, creativity begins with agency:
- The stronger one’s agency, the greater the freedom to explore and compare.
- More comparisons mean more connections and thus new thoughts.
- Thoughts in turn trigger emotions.
- There are no new emotions, but thoughts to which emotions are attached are infinite.
- Thought-emotion pairings produce images.
- The more thought-emotion pairings, the greater the variety of sight, sound, and written images.
- The deeper and more intense the images, the greater the beauty and more sublime the product.
Ta da – art, music, literature.
Brain and Heart
In varying degrees, we carry all emotions within us and they are brought to the surface by stimuli of the moment. A gunshot, for example, may trigger (sorry ‘bout that) fear; name-calling may cause anger; a full moon, romance. As thoughts activate emotions and emotions intensify thoughts, brain and heart work together and we feel our thoughts. The higher the intensity of this feeling, the longer the thought will be remembered and tinkered with.
Musicians and artists of all stripes are known for their deeper, intense emotions and their ability to remember. Thus thought-emotion pairings do more than seep into and infuse their work; they become their work as put to paper, paint, and the vibrations we call music.
One expert maintains that images and memories “pass colorfully and plastically through the souls of the artists” and the “early awakening of strong emotions in childhood is proven among many composers.” Further:
[An artist] “without extreme strength of memory for such recollections is just as unthinkable as the artist without an imagination that is capable of employing such recollections in new associations. … In the [ever-active] fantasy of the musician, emotions are preserved with the most minute gradations of color and rhythm.” 
If new associations are the essence of creativity, then the variety of color and rhythm gradations are the essence of beauty.
Naturally, we see positive emotions more often with robust agency because of freedom and power to act, and we appreciate a Mozart known for his playful mood, jokes and puns. But adversity with its negative emotions can also trigger creativity as one struggles with opposition, friction being a necessary component of agency and progress. Beethoven, for example, was grave and sullen, a bi-polar introvert and gloomy as a child. Many of his works reflect bipolar emotions. His Ninth Symphony ranges from somber to joyful, and his Egmont Overture is brooding and somber for ten of its eleven minutes and then in the final minute becomes one of the best examples of triumphal music.
Creativity in Heaven
Mozart, who this day certainly continues his craft, left us this great glimpse before going there:
“I have never written the music that was in my heart to write; perhaps I never shall with this brain and these fingers, but I know that hereafter it will be written; when instead of these few inlets of the senses through which we now secure impressions from without, there shall be a flood of impressions from all sides; and instead of these few tones of our little octave, there shall be an infinite scale of harmonies – for I feel it – I am sure of it. This world of music, whose borders even now I have scarcely entered, is a reality, is immortal.”
So back to the original question: If Napoleon had not invaded Russia, would Tchaikovsky still have written the 1812 Overture? I believe he would. It may have appeared in a slightly different form, but that music was in him.
It only would have required a different grain of Russian-history sand in his oyster.
* * *
Gary Lawrence is a public opinion pollster
and author in Orange County, California.
 Max Graf, From Beethoven to Shostakovich – The Psychology of the Composing Process, 1923, 92-96