Comments | Meridian Magazine

Sign up for our newsletter

   

Signed up, but still not getting our newsletter? Click here.

 

June 26, 2022

Comments | Return to Story

DouglasOctober 11, 2013

Theodore - your dogmatic view of what the Lord wants regarding those that call themselves "Jews" (with a significant descent NOT of Judah but of a Turkic peoples known as the Khazars which converted en masse to Judaism in the eighth century) and their conflict with the peoples that they disposessed from Palestine is part of what covers the atrocities that Israel visits upon its neighbors. It's not hard to figure out. The Zionists that settled in Palestine with British sponsorship (Balfour Declaration of 1917) have increased their foothold and driven out their Arab neighbors. We LDS, or Americans overall, should NOT get involved. Until we were friends with Israel, we had no enemies amongst the Muslim peoples.

Steve SSeptember 12, 2013

Steve (Sept. 8), I decided to answer your questions to weigh out which side occupies higher moral ground. 1) The Palestinian National Authority has held parliamentary, presidential, and local elections in 2005, 2006, 2010, and 2012. Israel does not allow four million of the twelve million people under its control to vote. 2) In 1937, the founder of Israel, David Ben Gurion, said, "We must expel Arabs and take their places." In 1976, Israel Koenig, member of the then ruling Alignment Party, wrote a secret memo which contained the phrase, "We must use terror, assassination, intimidation, land confiscation, and the cutting of all social services to rid the Galilee of its Arab population." 3) In 1914, on the eve or WWI, approximately a half a million Jews lived peaceably alongside their Muslim neighbors. The Ottoman Empire even allowed the Jews to have their own constitution in the 1860s. Jewish forces caused the expulsion of some 750,000 Arabs from their homes in 1948.

SteveSeptember 12, 2013

Thanks for the balanced view Dr. Ogden. Unfortunately lots of people have strong opinions about Israel and the Palestinians without much knowledge. The fact of the matter is that in 1967 Israel occupied the Arab-inhabited West Bank and Gaza Strip. The 4 million Arabs who inhabit these regions do not have equal rights in Israel. They do not have Israeli citizenship, they can't vote, they have no recourse in Israeli courts in the event of a grievance involving an Israeli citizen, the Palestinian territories are not an internationally recognized sovereign state, the Palestinians in these territories do not have the freedom of movement even within the territories themselves, and for every Israeli that has been killed in the Israeli-Palestinian conflicts since 2000, seven Palestinians have been killed. Israel occupies the lands inhabited by the Palestinians, therefore they are responsible for their welfare and must either find a way to integrate them into an unified Israeli state and give them equal status or make way for the creation of an independent Palestinian state. The Palestinians have their hands tied by Israel. How do they bear most of the blame for the conflict?

SteveSeptember 8, 2013

Three questions we should ask ourselves when weighing which side in this political conflict truly occupies the high moral ground: 1) Which side espouses democracy as its cherished political system? 2) Which side has never suggested wiping any of its neighbors off the face of the earth? 3) Which side not only allows, but encourages its peaceful neighbors to live within its borders, while the other side would never allow such heresy? May be this issue should be viewed in a simpler way than some wish to portray it....

ChuckSeptember 8, 2013

Well, if Israel is no Goliath; if they were, they would simply annihilate their enemies. Hundreds of thousands of Arabs live quite peacefully in Israel, thank you. Israels are doing more than their part for peace. It is those who think Israel must be destroyed who perceive Israel to be belligerent and vengeful. It is true: If the Palestinians et al. would lay down their weapons, there would be peace for all; if Israelis did the same they would be wiped out. To be impartial is not to consider these facts. By the way, we have given millions of aid to the Palestinians, who use it to rain missiles down on Israel. Israel's excesses are an inevitable result of persecution -- the LDS in the same situation avoided such only because of prophetic counsel, and the ability to simply move away. Israel has neither.

Tom ArmitageSeptember 7, 2013

Your political agenda seems to be showing. Palestinians have and do live peacefully within Israel. The Israelis do no espouse the annihalation of Palestininas rather the reverse. The entire Arab world at one time or another has called for the destruction of Israel. Israel is a geographic and economic spec when compared to the Arab countries, If the Arabs were so concerned about the Palestinians why not set aside land for them. Sorry but you won't see me rushing to the aid of the Palestinians any time soon.

JamesSeptember 6, 2013

We know Jerusalem is a sacred place. Any who have visited it also know everybody in the city hates everybody else in the city. Can't even remember how many houses in which Mary was supposed to have been born, and there are at least as many money changers and pushy street vendors as there likely were in the time of Jesus. My one pleasant experience, was seeing two young Arab brothers react to customers of their small Mom and Pop store. They were kind to customers, to passersby, to a small boy who lost his first tooth, and even to me, as I sat on Lion's Gate, across from their stand. All other experiences made me want to leave the city ASAP.

Judith NeedhamSeptember 6, 2013

Thank you for the open minded comments. I look forward to getting the book and reading it. As always, nothing is absolute except God's truth.

JaySeptember 6, 2013

Thank you, Dr. Ogden, for reminding us that things are often not as simple as they may first seem.

Theodore BrandleySeptember 6, 2013

Kelly, I love you, but there is no moral equivalency between the Muslim attempts to destroy Israel and Israel

herm olsenSeptember 6, 2013

Excellent observations! Bro. Ogden has correctly observed that there really ARE two sides to every story. I know God isn't pleased with all of the behavior of either side to this drama. Our role should be to love and serve and support the positive behaviors of both sides, when those positive elements emerge.

ADD A COMMENT

  • INSPIRATION FOR LIVING A LATTER-DAY SAINT LIFE

    Daily news, articles, videos and podcasts sent straight to your inbox.