Ellis: my white son was shot in the face and killed at a traffic stop by an arrogant, incompetent cop. Please stop thinking that it only happens to black guys. The cop claimed it was an accident, so he had immunity from punishment.
MylesSeptember 5, 2020
Thank you for writing this article perfectly. It’s what I always believe. I vote for principles not color.
Karen L.September 2, 2020
This article os typical of someone who has no idea what its like to be a POC. When you have your young women’s president call you a racial slur and other members of the church lump you into a category of other minorities, without getting to know you, then you can write with some weight. The second commandment is to love our neighbor. Don’t throw out all the goodness that is being brought about by just looking at the negative aspects.
Mark WadsworthAugust 29, 2020
Great article! Jesus Christ loves and knows us as an individual. To Satan we are commodity, like a herd of cattle or sheep. The better follow Christ example the happier we will be.
Frances DalleyAugust 21, 2020
So well said and what I feel and think, but did not have the articulate language to do so. Thank you for expressing social justice and cancel culture in terms that provoke critical thinking so as to not confuse the philosophies of men with scriptural doctrine. Marxism is a great concern right now, and needs to be.
Craig NelsonAugust 21, 2020
Studying this weeks CFM - as I read Helaman 5:51 I fear and I hope or have faith that the inequalities in our world today are because of the “traditions of our fathers” and that we will lay down our weapons of war and our hatred....
CarolynAugust 17, 2020
Very disappointed to see so many people using this piece to validate bigotry. Arguing that “social justice ideology” or the current civil rights movement is in any way antithetical to the gospel of Christ is extremely dangerous, as I’m seeing too many people weaponize this idea into racism in the name of the Church. Remember that Christ left the 99 for the one; we should do the same.
David StokerAugust 17, 2020
Thank you for this article. I believe if people would read it through the lens of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, they would understand the truths you brought out. The basic, golden rule of do unto others as you would have them do unto you would solve so many of societies problems. I have read some of the comments and am convinced that they are missing the mark of what the Lord would have us do in being free from the destructive philosophies of mankind and rely on the spirit of the Gospel.
Jim RodgetsAugust 17, 2020
Excellent article; THANKS for sharing!!
Personally, I think the author was spot-on in her analysis...but did not go far enough in her fundamental conclusions.
To wit: critical race theory, social justice, et al, are not just flawed social constructs or models for social behavior. They are far worse than that. The author was perhaps seeking to be polite.
In fact, those ideological constructs are expressly designed to further three fundamental goals:
1. DESTROY religious values and standards.
2. DESTROY the traditional family order ordained by God.
3. OVERTHROW the existing Constitutional government and our Constitution itself, and implement Communism as the new ruling form of government in the USA.
There's no need to be polite or gentle in our characterization of critical theory and its variants: THEY UNALTERABLY OPPOSE OUR HEAVENLY FATHER'S PLAN OF SALVATION.
Thus, critical theory, in all its variants, is simply another tool of the Great Deceiver, the Father of All Lies...Satan himself.
There is no laudable goal offered by these man-made ideologies that is not better achieved through fullybliving the True Gospel.
Members of the Church of Jesus Christ should not, MUST NOT, be deceived by these man-made ideologies. Down that path lies dilution of Gospel principles, a withdrawal of the Spirit and, eventually, apostasy.
Be strong and careful, Children of our Heavey Father.
Choose wisely. Choose love.
Choose Christ!!!
Claire AuatinAugust 17, 2020
I can’t NOT comment again about this article. Our baptismal covenant is to mourn with those who mourn. This doesn’t mean just to have sympathy or empathy for those suffering in the world. It means acting upon the problems, disparities and injustices of the world. Yes, many races are racist, but does that mean we should be? I am a white privileged woman who just wants to learn from others, then help them make their lives and systems better. I will continue to be involved in social justice.
JenniferAugust 17, 2020
Excellent article! Thank you for so meticulously laying out each point. Satan wants a little bit of scripture mingled with the philosophies of man so that he can lead us astray... and that is exactly what I believe social justice is. The BLM mission statement is in complete opposition to the Family Proclamation. Marxism is Satan’s plan!!
Miriam SmithAugust 16, 2020
Whatever issues one may have with the philosophies of those who have written about social justice, we have been commanded to practice social justice--to love our neighbor as ourselves and to "Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you."
We should be doers, not complainers.
As Elder Holland taught, may we be equally committed to freeing the world from the virus of hunger, freeing neighborhoods and nations from the virus of poverty. May we hope for schools where students are taught—not terrified they will be shot—and for the gift of personal dignity for every child of God, unmarred by any form of racial, ethnic, or religious prejudice.
That is social justice.
Martin LutherAugust 16, 2020
Critical social justice pursues and evangelizes many false ideas. First, that equality of outcome is the goal. Second, that the only way to get there is to attack people as privileged or not black enough. Third, that the country and flag have to be disrespected to take a stand. Fourth, that capitalism must be set aside to be replaced by Marxism in spite of its complete lack of success. Fifth, that misbehavior should be lauded and celebrated. Sixth, that there is no conflict of interest in accepting donations to fight racism only to be used for purchasing political power. Seventh, that the racist practices and past of Planned Parenthood should be ignored. Eighth, that generational control of inner cities by one political party has not been a complete failure. And finally that groups like BLM have any desire to correct the racism that it milks for donations, sponsored by popular news media which does the same--milk it for viewership, ratings, and dollars.
David GlennAugust 16, 2020
Thank you for writing this. Something always seemed off about these movements, and the more I saw what they championed the more I wanted to stay away from it. The messages and means they use to enforce their ideology upon the rest of the world just never seemed to resonate with what Heavenly Father has taught. I'm just glad I chose to stand with what I had been taught in the church.
Steven WatsonAugust 16, 2020
This article is worrisome because a casual or un-careful reading by (particularly white) LDS readers could easily sway them into believing any active social justice efforts are antithetical to the gospel. This belief will stifle our progress toward better Christian discipleship as individuals and as a Church.
Jason McElprangAugust 16, 2020
This is perfect! I wish my discussions with friends and family had been this articulit, thank you for sharing this! I had never thought of the "original sin" perspective, that struck me as a perfect example of why I should not be ashamed of being born into my circumstances.
SandyAugust 16, 2020
This article nails it head on. I appreciated the well thought out and honest views.
Yes, many will disagree. I think those that disagree have chosen to follow perhaps a portion of this movement. But, they've got their foot in the door down a very shady path. I believe progress was already being made before this movement was slammed in our faces. Perhaps others do not think it was moving fast enough. Change takes time and this life is not our only chance to progress (although it's the most preferred).
People have to be allowed their agency... meaning many (even in the church) will choose other paths. That is their right, and we should have ours as well to follow Christ. Our freedoms are being stripped away at an unprecedented rate. I hope other wake up in time.
Sherri EinfeldtAugust 16, 2020
Spot on! I have been thinking all those things for a very long time but it was nice to have someone actually publish them. Thank you for a clear and accurate perspective.
John ScheidAugust 16, 2020
In reading through both the article and the comments there many good points made for both sides of the social justice ideology being put forward. Christ should be the center and focus of all we pursue. The philosophies of men/women without the perspective of a Christ centered life open the door for Satan to influence and lead one astray. The thought comes to mind that “the very elect will be led astray” Should be uppermost in the mind of any who study these philosophies lest one find themselves succumbing to feelings of anger that is rationalized as “what would Jesus do?” Some who have been the victim of racism, sexism, etc experience strong feelings based on those experiences. What one does with those experiences and associated feelings will likely determine your personal views. Having been a victim myself of stereotypical things experienced during my lifetime I could have chosen completely different paths for my life. I’m far from perfect but I believe that judging on the side of mercy and recognizing that others view the world through the lens of their life experiences has helped me. I have a long way to go. That said individual responsibility and accountability are core and key parts of the mortal journey. To allow the philosophies of men to sway your thoughts otherwise place you at the mercy of Satan. He has no mercy and his only goal is your misery become like his. Standing up against those philosophies is standing up against the father of all lies. Giving in to anger and justifying it denies Christ and His teachings regarding the source of all anger. Speaking out against lies, deceit, anger and the philosophies of men do not make one guilty or ignorant of social justice.
Joel WashburnAugust 15, 2020
I appreciated your ideas, especially ways we can go about important societal change without resorting to violence and having to become part of an ideology that runs counter to my own beliefs. Racism in all of its forms is always horrible and should always be fought against but in the right way. Keep up the great work!
JpAugust 15, 2020
It focuses on social salvation rather than individual salvation.
EllisAugust 15, 2020
We have black brothers and sisters struggling right now. Why are we getting a feel-good article nitpicking everything wrong with social justice, instead of maybe some tips on how we can better mourn with those who mourn, and help our black brothers and sisters?
Sorry, this is all very close to me. My black friend’s brother was shot and killed by a cop recently. Routine traffic stop, the cop had his gun pulled because he was nervous around a black man. Accidentally pulled the trigger. And now this good black father is dead, all because of the color of his skin. This story never made the news here in Utah, but these sorts of stories are well known in black communities. It scars them. The last thing they need are their white brothers and sisters lulled into inaction by articles like this one.
Kimberly SmithAugust 15, 2020
Love the article. I have thought that Satan is using 10% truth and 90% lies to counter the Plan of Salvation with the social justice movement as it is displayed currently.
Warren HessAugust 15, 2020
By their fruits ye shall know them.
Laura PendorfAugust 14, 2020
Love one another as I have loved you.
Pam TooneAugust 14, 2020
“we can recognize that any secular belief system that appears to substitute for religion can only lead us away from Christ.“ This is an important part of this article. The social justice movement, by and large, does want to substitute religion for this secular group. It absolutely will take you away from Christ so subtly, you won’t recognize it until it’s too late. Great article, thank you!
Wendy JensenAugust 14, 2020
Thank-you for your research and well thought out presentation as to the problem of well-intentioned efforts to solve critical issues of our day. Many have been shamed, bullied really, when they attempt to add thoughts or considerations that do not fit the “acceptable ideology” on important matters. We are losing when we cannot counsel together and when we close off free speech and refuse to hear others through bullying tactics.
Melissa D. B.August 14, 2020
Good article. Good comments. Another thing that occurred to me is that these beliefs interfere with the Plan of Salvation because you take repentance and forgiveness out of the realm of each individual and you say it's a group requirement. So the "oppressor" group cannot receive forgiveness (for things they may not have even done themselves, and the "oppressed" group are told they are not in need of repentance for the things they do. A counterfeit that mixes good ideas w/very damaging ones.
Harold RustAugust 14, 2020
I really appreciated the wisdom and "calmness" in this article. As I read those responses which seemed to condemn the essence of your perspective, I felt a rise in the hatred and finger-pointing and self-righteousness which so often accompanies those out to see others as either a perpetrator or a victim. As I shared with a close neighbor of mine, my experience has taught me that if you really want to improve how others show respect and compassion, then give them ten stories of when individuals demonstrated that trait for every one story in which injustice or some "ism" occurred. We improve each other when we seek out what works, not when we taunt others with an example of what didn't work or wasn't fair or just.
I would hope that those who vocally oppose this article will actually look inward and ask themselves if they aren't creating more hatred when they look for and highlight what they think are hateful actions in others.
And, yes, I will do the same and might write this response differently in the future by highlighting important lessons I've learned from others who initially think differently than I do.
James HarrisAugust 14, 2020
As disciples of Jesus Christ, we ought to do all we can to redeem others from suffering and burdens. Even so, our greatest redemptive service will be to lead them to Christ. Without His Redemption from death and from sin, we have only a gospel of social justice. That may provide some help and reconciliation in the present, but it has no power to draw down from heaven perfect justice and infinite mercy. Ultimate redemption is in Jesus Christ and in Him alone. I humbly and gratefully acknowledge Him as the Redeemer in the name of Jesus Christ, amen.
D. Todd Christofferson, “Redemption,” Ensign, May 2013
Jennifer BrennerAugust 13, 2020
I think that what your article suggests in its totality is that nothing should be done. That we ignore the injustices of oppressed people over the course of history which has resulted in unfair conditions in the present under the guise that a few scholars are off by a hair or two from our theology as you interpret it.
How convenient a position a position for the dominant group? They don't support my view completely, I am out.
Take the broad view, that is what Christ would do. I believe that He expects us as his disciples to move to right the wrongs, the biases, the hurt, the lost opportunities of so many minority groups. No one is asking your swear allegiance to a cause, they are simply asking you to love your neighbor.
Claire AustinAugust 13, 2020
Social justice is so often associated with socialism or communism. It seems to me that social justice is what Christ wants us to live and foster in the world. . Just as God wanted the early saints to live the united order in order to give all the benefits of social justice to everyone, we should work for the same unity today. Dependence relies on interdependence. God relies on so many institutions and churches other than ours to further His work. Let’s all work to make a better world. Please...no more articles that divide us politically.
Scott WoodburyAugust 13, 2020
Great article. I see "social justice" as just another method of the great counterfeiter. Change must first come from within each individual. Comments from some about how God should or would act (and as an extension to try to force others to behave or believe the same way) is part of that counterfeit - similar, in a way, to someone telling me to stop paying tithing, and to give that money to some other charity that they deem is "worthy".
Dave GAugust 13, 2020
I think this article is very confusing. There are so many contradictory statements in the article.
Social Justice Ideology as it's called in the article is mixed bag there are some good things about it and some bad, but I don't think we should throw out the good just because bsome are doing bad things in the name of Social Justice Ideology.
As long as long as you stick to what good 8n the Ideology the bad shouldn't be an issue.
Shannon WixomAugust 12, 2020
Great article!! Totally agree with these thoughts, scripture references, etc. Especially as I have been seeking for the Holy Ghost to help me discern between truth and error. In this current age of much confusion, contention and misinformation, we must do as our prophet counsels, to do whatever it takes to hear Him.
MarshaAugust 12, 2020
This is an exceptional article. The "social justice" movement as it exists today is highly destructive and not what many members of the church,who naively support it, believe it to be. Just look at the BLM movement (part of the "social justice" family). It's insisting on and teaching people they must acknowledge their "white privilege" which is teaching people there is something fundamentally wrong with their skin color. That is, by definition, racism.
MarenAugust 12, 2020
Thank you for putting into clear form the thoughts that have been percolating in my head and heart. Having moved through the era of Civil Rigjts in the ‘60’s, I find this new ideology one of very subtle tokenism. Thank you for your clarity. Your use of parallelism is beautifully written, by the way!
Nancy CavanaughAugust 11, 2020
I think some of the premise you define as social justice is a faulty narrative and does a disservice to a serious social issue that needs the support of Christians who believe that loving our neighbor is more than words.
Don SearleAugust 11, 2020
Excellent! Thank you, Rebecca.I plan to share this.
M. HomerAugust 11, 2020
Please read the whole statement from the BLM website regarding "families." They are opposed to the idea that a family unit be so rigidly defined, not that families should be dismantled. This statement is a simple way of saying everyone is part of our family and we will fight for everyone.
From BLM: "We disrupt the Western-prescribed nuclear family structure requirement by supporting each other as extended families and “villages” that collectively care for one another, especially our children, to the degree that mothers, parents, and children are comfortable."
Michael Van WormerAugust 10, 2020
Outstanding article! Interestingly, the tactic of classifying people as the oppressed and the oppressors has been at the heart of Marxist ideology since its onset. It has been used to incite class warfare and to topple existing power structures. It is being used today by those that are ignorant of history and encouraged by those who have sought to implement their agenda for decades.
Daniel LarsonAugust 10, 2020
No mention of social justice in the Roman Catholic tradition. Perhaps some value may be found there. It’s a disservice to ignore other approaches to social justice if readers believe that this article covers the issue thoroughly.
AlysonAugust 10, 2020
Great article. I would be lost at this time without the gospel of Jesus Christ. I would be like the foolish man who built his house upon the sand, but instead, I I have the rock of the gospel of Jesus Christ and the prophets and apostles who are not blown by every wind of doctrine. I love the primary song, “Jesus said love everyone, treat them kindly too. When your heart is filled with love, others will love you.”
Merrill Van LeuvenAugust 10, 2020
Well written, well stated. These are my thoughts, just expressed so much more eloquently with experts weighing in. I appreciate this examination of critical social justice. Thank you!
Oliver NesbittAugust 10, 2020
A very positive and informative article, but not everyone is a member of the church and indeed knows nothing about the church. Where do we turn for social justice because we know not where to find it
TannerAugust 10, 2020
While this makes some good points regarding cancel culture and the importance of the family. I fundamentally disagree with the content and rhetoric of this article. I feel that it takes many points out of context and is misleading in its connections to the gospel. I don’t understand how striving to overcome a racist past as a society or a church is inconsistent with coming unto Christ. I believe Christ would stand up for the marginalized and would seek the fair treatment of others. This article has undertones of justification and rationalization. White members of the Chirch of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints are not the victims of the current social injustice at hand and we should not seek to justify our privilege. Again, just one mans opinion, thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Alyssum DunnAugust 10, 2020
Rebecca Taylor, you are spot on in what you have written about Social Justice Ideology. I don't think you need to be an "educated" person to understand what you have written. I have personal experience of how this ideology is man made, that it doesn't reflect how Heavenly Father feels and Jesus Christ feels about us and how we treat each other. It only creates more division than harmony. I try to share my experience and I am shut down when I do so. I appreciate you putting it into the perfect words to show how this ideology isn't in harmony with the Gospel of Jesus Christ!
Theodore BrandleyAugust 10, 2020
Social justice ideology is an integral philosophy of Marxism, which is the antithesis of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Marxism is the foundation theory of Communism and its modern version called Progressivism.
Elsa DuboisAugust 10, 2020
I’ve held my tongue but this!!!!!!
Thank you for unashamedly pointing out the truth. People accuse you if spoke up against the movement ( not the slogan!) for being unfeeling and unkind for expressing the same principles we’ve been taught using basic gospel doctrine in their attempt to steer and stress the very same principles but by using the pseudo subversive vernacular of the time. It really made me feel that the adversary’s power overcame people ever do subtly and deceivingly under this great cloak of pretense.And yes, as prophesied even the elect fell for it!!!!
Heather DubachAugust 10, 2020
I loved this article!
Becky BuxtonAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for this. I have objected to "social justice" because of the reasons you articulated, but I wasn't able to. Thank you for the research and facts.
Nerita Flake PetersonAugust 10, 2020
this was thoughtful, reasonable and logical. Thanks you so much.
Laura BeeymanAugust 10, 2020
Excellent! Thank you.
Aleisa EatonAugust 10, 2020
Wonderful article! Well researched, succinct and understandable.
Judith SmithAugust 10, 2020
Glenn Beck warned against social justice Y E A R S ago.
Carol AnnAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for an outstanding and strong voice of reason!
R BluthAugust 10, 2020
Very well written. Thank you for your content
David DurfeeAugust 10, 2020
Another view is that for the very first time in 2000 years we have a broad social movement that at its core (its core, mind you) is completely in synch with the Savior's Second Great Commandment. To me that feels inspiring. And maybe even inspired.
Robert StarlingAugust 10, 2020
While this article requires careful reading to gain its full impact, the author is spot-on with her analysis and comparison of this man-made ideology with the perfection of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. "Social Justice Warriors" amongst us are mis-informed and deluded by the "philosophies of men". As usual, the way to find truth is FTP - Follow The Prophet. And the truth will make us free.
ReedAugust 10, 2020
Exceptionally well researched and presented.
CarolineAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for this well-written and well-researched article. I’m saving it!
NanetteAugust 10, 2020
My question is why do only white people have to recognize racism? What about the Blacks addressing their racism against white people? Thank u for this wonderful article I know we needed.
PattieAugust 10, 2020
Thank you, thank you and thank you. I have been trying to make this statement to others but you have said it so well. Social Justice is only for the minority and is truly Satan led. I have contemplated the phrase “BlackLives Matter” , it is a racist phrase fueling the fire of hatred between races. The young lady who died because she said, All Lives Matter” didn’t have the opportunity to raise her son because of this racial phrase. She was ambushed and killed by men whose only thoughts were to destroy anyone who doesn’t think like us. What a great topic for you, you need to write a book on this very subject.
Cynthia PAugust 10, 2020
What an excellent, thorough treatment of this sensitive subject! I loved the sources you quoted - especially James Lindsay.
Lawrence M BarryAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for putting to words what I've been thinking and feeling about the social justice movement but was unable to understand until I read your article.
Kayleen HunsakerAugust 10, 2020
What a great article!
It puts all the truth about this situation of "Social Justice Ideology" in a comprehensive and easily understood format.
It helped me to understand why I was feeling so many "red flags" about everything going on-knowing it was not following Jesus Christ.
Thank you for all your research and time to write this.
D. GoodwinAugust 10, 2020
I think this article was written for academics, and for the rest of the Meridian audiance, I thought it will be confusing and in some instances, misleading. Perhaps I just don't have the background in social psychology that I needed, but I was not convinced that I should be "concerned." To oppose an injustice (even through the lens of hindsight) is the same as condoning it, in my mind.
Comments | Return to Story
SiouxSeptember 25, 2020
Ellis: my white son was shot in the face and killed at a traffic stop by an arrogant, incompetent cop. Please stop thinking that it only happens to black guys. The cop claimed it was an accident, so he had immunity from punishment.
MylesSeptember 5, 2020
Thank you for writing this article perfectly. It’s what I always believe. I vote for principles not color.
Karen L.September 2, 2020
This article os typical of someone who has no idea what its like to be a POC. When you have your young women’s president call you a racial slur and other members of the church lump you into a category of other minorities, without getting to know you, then you can write with some weight. The second commandment is to love our neighbor. Don’t throw out all the goodness that is being brought about by just looking at the negative aspects.
Mark WadsworthAugust 29, 2020
Great article! Jesus Christ loves and knows us as an individual. To Satan we are commodity, like a herd of cattle or sheep. The better follow Christ example the happier we will be.
Frances DalleyAugust 21, 2020
So well said and what I feel and think, but did not have the articulate language to do so. Thank you for expressing social justice and cancel culture in terms that provoke critical thinking so as to not confuse the philosophies of men with scriptural doctrine. Marxism is a great concern right now, and needs to be.
Craig NelsonAugust 21, 2020
Studying this weeks CFM - as I read Helaman 5:51 I fear and I hope or have faith that the inequalities in our world today are because of the “traditions of our fathers” and that we will lay down our weapons of war and our hatred....
CarolynAugust 17, 2020
Very disappointed to see so many people using this piece to validate bigotry. Arguing that “social justice ideology” or the current civil rights movement is in any way antithetical to the gospel of Christ is extremely dangerous, as I’m seeing too many people weaponize this idea into racism in the name of the Church. Remember that Christ left the 99 for the one; we should do the same.
David StokerAugust 17, 2020
Thank you for this article. I believe if people would read it through the lens of the Gospel of Jesus Christ, they would understand the truths you brought out. The basic, golden rule of do unto others as you would have them do unto you would solve so many of societies problems. I have read some of the comments and am convinced that they are missing the mark of what the Lord would have us do in being free from the destructive philosophies of mankind and rely on the spirit of the Gospel.
Jim RodgetsAugust 17, 2020
Excellent article; THANKS for sharing!! Personally, I think the author was spot-on in her analysis...but did not go far enough in her fundamental conclusions. To wit: critical race theory, social justice, et al, are not just flawed social constructs or models for social behavior. They are far worse than that. The author was perhaps seeking to be polite. In fact, those ideological constructs are expressly designed to further three fundamental goals: 1. DESTROY religious values and standards. 2. DESTROY the traditional family order ordained by God. 3. OVERTHROW the existing Constitutional government and our Constitution itself, and implement Communism as the new ruling form of government in the USA. There's no need to be polite or gentle in our characterization of critical theory and its variants: THEY UNALTERABLY OPPOSE OUR HEAVENLY FATHER'S PLAN OF SALVATION. Thus, critical theory, in all its variants, is simply another tool of the Great Deceiver, the Father of All Lies...Satan himself. There is no laudable goal offered by these man-made ideologies that is not better achieved through fullybliving the True Gospel. Members of the Church of Jesus Christ should not, MUST NOT, be deceived by these man-made ideologies. Down that path lies dilution of Gospel principles, a withdrawal of the Spirit and, eventually, apostasy. Be strong and careful, Children of our Heavey Father. Choose wisely. Choose love. Choose Christ!!!
Claire AuatinAugust 17, 2020
I can’t NOT comment again about this article. Our baptismal covenant is to mourn with those who mourn. This doesn’t mean just to have sympathy or empathy for those suffering in the world. It means acting upon the problems, disparities and injustices of the world. Yes, many races are racist, but does that mean we should be? I am a white privileged woman who just wants to learn from others, then help them make their lives and systems better. I will continue to be involved in social justice.
JenniferAugust 17, 2020
Excellent article! Thank you for so meticulously laying out each point. Satan wants a little bit of scripture mingled with the philosophies of man so that he can lead us astray... and that is exactly what I believe social justice is. The BLM mission statement is in complete opposition to the Family Proclamation. Marxism is Satan’s plan!!
Miriam SmithAugust 16, 2020
Whatever issues one may have with the philosophies of those who have written about social justice, we have been commanded to practice social justice--to love our neighbor as ourselves and to "Love your enemies, bless them that curse you, do good to them that hate you, and pray for them which despitefully use you, and persecute you." We should be doers, not complainers. As Elder Holland taught, may we be equally committed to freeing the world from the virus of hunger, freeing neighborhoods and nations from the virus of poverty. May we hope for schools where students are taught—not terrified they will be shot—and for the gift of personal dignity for every child of God, unmarred by any form of racial, ethnic, or religious prejudice. That is social justice.
Martin LutherAugust 16, 2020
Critical social justice pursues and evangelizes many false ideas. First, that equality of outcome is the goal. Second, that the only way to get there is to attack people as privileged or not black enough. Third, that the country and flag have to be disrespected to take a stand. Fourth, that capitalism must be set aside to be replaced by Marxism in spite of its complete lack of success. Fifth, that misbehavior should be lauded and celebrated. Sixth, that there is no conflict of interest in accepting donations to fight racism only to be used for purchasing political power. Seventh, that the racist practices and past of Planned Parenthood should be ignored. Eighth, that generational control of inner cities by one political party has not been a complete failure. And finally that groups like BLM have any desire to correct the racism that it milks for donations, sponsored by popular news media which does the same--milk it for viewership, ratings, and dollars.
David GlennAugust 16, 2020
Thank you for writing this. Something always seemed off about these movements, and the more I saw what they championed the more I wanted to stay away from it. The messages and means they use to enforce their ideology upon the rest of the world just never seemed to resonate with what Heavenly Father has taught. I'm just glad I chose to stand with what I had been taught in the church.
Steven WatsonAugust 16, 2020
This article is worrisome because a casual or un-careful reading by (particularly white) LDS readers could easily sway them into believing any active social justice efforts are antithetical to the gospel. This belief will stifle our progress toward better Christian discipleship as individuals and as a Church.
Jason McElprangAugust 16, 2020
This is perfect! I wish my discussions with friends and family had been this articulit, thank you for sharing this! I had never thought of the "original sin" perspective, that struck me as a perfect example of why I should not be ashamed of being born into my circumstances.
SandyAugust 16, 2020
This article nails it head on. I appreciated the well thought out and honest views. Yes, many will disagree. I think those that disagree have chosen to follow perhaps a portion of this movement. But, they've got their foot in the door down a very shady path. I believe progress was already being made before this movement was slammed in our faces. Perhaps others do not think it was moving fast enough. Change takes time and this life is not our only chance to progress (although it's the most preferred). People have to be allowed their agency... meaning many (even in the church) will choose other paths. That is their right, and we should have ours as well to follow Christ. Our freedoms are being stripped away at an unprecedented rate. I hope other wake up in time.
Sherri EinfeldtAugust 16, 2020
Spot on! I have been thinking all those things for a very long time but it was nice to have someone actually publish them. Thank you for a clear and accurate perspective.
John ScheidAugust 16, 2020
In reading through both the article and the comments there many good points made for both sides of the social justice ideology being put forward. Christ should be the center and focus of all we pursue. The philosophies of men/women without the perspective of a Christ centered life open the door for Satan to influence and lead one astray. The thought comes to mind that “the very elect will be led astray” Should be uppermost in the mind of any who study these philosophies lest one find themselves succumbing to feelings of anger that is rationalized as “what would Jesus do?” Some who have been the victim of racism, sexism, etc experience strong feelings based on those experiences. What one does with those experiences and associated feelings will likely determine your personal views. Having been a victim myself of stereotypical things experienced during my lifetime I could have chosen completely different paths for my life. I’m far from perfect but I believe that judging on the side of mercy and recognizing that others view the world through the lens of their life experiences has helped me. I have a long way to go. That said individual responsibility and accountability are core and key parts of the mortal journey. To allow the philosophies of men to sway your thoughts otherwise place you at the mercy of Satan. He has no mercy and his only goal is your misery become like his. Standing up against those philosophies is standing up against the father of all lies. Giving in to anger and justifying it denies Christ and His teachings regarding the source of all anger. Speaking out against lies, deceit, anger and the philosophies of men do not make one guilty or ignorant of social justice.
Joel WashburnAugust 15, 2020
I appreciated your ideas, especially ways we can go about important societal change without resorting to violence and having to become part of an ideology that runs counter to my own beliefs. Racism in all of its forms is always horrible and should always be fought against but in the right way. Keep up the great work!
JpAugust 15, 2020
It focuses on social salvation rather than individual salvation.
EllisAugust 15, 2020
We have black brothers and sisters struggling right now. Why are we getting a feel-good article nitpicking everything wrong with social justice, instead of maybe some tips on how we can better mourn with those who mourn, and help our black brothers and sisters? Sorry, this is all very close to me. My black friend’s brother was shot and killed by a cop recently. Routine traffic stop, the cop had his gun pulled because he was nervous around a black man. Accidentally pulled the trigger. And now this good black father is dead, all because of the color of his skin. This story never made the news here in Utah, but these sorts of stories are well known in black communities. It scars them. The last thing they need are their white brothers and sisters lulled into inaction by articles like this one.
Kimberly SmithAugust 15, 2020
Love the article. I have thought that Satan is using 10% truth and 90% lies to counter the Plan of Salvation with the social justice movement as it is displayed currently.
Warren HessAugust 15, 2020
By their fruits ye shall know them.
Laura PendorfAugust 14, 2020
Love one another as I have loved you.
Pam TooneAugust 14, 2020
“we can recognize that any secular belief system that appears to substitute for religion can only lead us away from Christ.“ This is an important part of this article. The social justice movement, by and large, does want to substitute religion for this secular group. It absolutely will take you away from Christ so subtly, you won’t recognize it until it’s too late. Great article, thank you!
Wendy JensenAugust 14, 2020
Thank-you for your research and well thought out presentation as to the problem of well-intentioned efforts to solve critical issues of our day. Many have been shamed, bullied really, when they attempt to add thoughts or considerations that do not fit the “acceptable ideology” on important matters. We are losing when we cannot counsel together and when we close off free speech and refuse to hear others through bullying tactics.
Melissa D. B.August 14, 2020
Good article. Good comments. Another thing that occurred to me is that these beliefs interfere with the Plan of Salvation because you take repentance and forgiveness out of the realm of each individual and you say it's a group requirement. So the "oppressor" group cannot receive forgiveness (for things they may not have even done themselves, and the "oppressed" group are told they are not in need of repentance for the things they do. A counterfeit that mixes good ideas w/very damaging ones.
Harold RustAugust 14, 2020
I really appreciated the wisdom and "calmness" in this article. As I read those responses which seemed to condemn the essence of your perspective, I felt a rise in the hatred and finger-pointing and self-righteousness which so often accompanies those out to see others as either a perpetrator or a victim. As I shared with a close neighbor of mine, my experience has taught me that if you really want to improve how others show respect and compassion, then give them ten stories of when individuals demonstrated that trait for every one story in which injustice or some "ism" occurred. We improve each other when we seek out what works, not when we taunt others with an example of what didn't work or wasn't fair or just. I would hope that those who vocally oppose this article will actually look inward and ask themselves if they aren't creating more hatred when they look for and highlight what they think are hateful actions in others. And, yes, I will do the same and might write this response differently in the future by highlighting important lessons I've learned from others who initially think differently than I do.
James HarrisAugust 14, 2020
As disciples of Jesus Christ, we ought to do all we can to redeem others from suffering and burdens. Even so, our greatest redemptive service will be to lead them to Christ. Without His Redemption from death and from sin, we have only a gospel of social justice. That may provide some help and reconciliation in the present, but it has no power to draw down from heaven perfect justice and infinite mercy. Ultimate redemption is in Jesus Christ and in Him alone. I humbly and gratefully acknowledge Him as the Redeemer in the name of Jesus Christ, amen. D. Todd Christofferson, “Redemption,” Ensign, May 2013
Jennifer BrennerAugust 13, 2020
I think that what your article suggests in its totality is that nothing should be done. That we ignore the injustices of oppressed people over the course of history which has resulted in unfair conditions in the present under the guise that a few scholars are off by a hair or two from our theology as you interpret it. How convenient a position a position for the dominant group? They don't support my view completely, I am out. Take the broad view, that is what Christ would do. I believe that He expects us as his disciples to move to right the wrongs, the biases, the hurt, the lost opportunities of so many minority groups. No one is asking your swear allegiance to a cause, they are simply asking you to love your neighbor.
Claire AustinAugust 13, 2020
Social justice is so often associated with socialism or communism. It seems to me that social justice is what Christ wants us to live and foster in the world. . Just as God wanted the early saints to live the united order in order to give all the benefits of social justice to everyone, we should work for the same unity today. Dependence relies on interdependence. God relies on so many institutions and churches other than ours to further His work. Let’s all work to make a better world. Please...no more articles that divide us politically.
Scott WoodburyAugust 13, 2020
Great article. I see "social justice" as just another method of the great counterfeiter. Change must first come from within each individual. Comments from some about how God should or would act (and as an extension to try to force others to behave or believe the same way) is part of that counterfeit - similar, in a way, to someone telling me to stop paying tithing, and to give that money to some other charity that they deem is "worthy".
Dave GAugust 13, 2020
I think this article is very confusing. There are so many contradictory statements in the article. Social Justice Ideology as it's called in the article is mixed bag there are some good things about it and some bad, but I don't think we should throw out the good just because bsome are doing bad things in the name of Social Justice Ideology. As long as long as you stick to what good 8n the Ideology the bad shouldn't be an issue.
Shannon WixomAugust 12, 2020
Great article!! Totally agree with these thoughts, scripture references, etc. Especially as I have been seeking for the Holy Ghost to help me discern between truth and error. In this current age of much confusion, contention and misinformation, we must do as our prophet counsels, to do whatever it takes to hear Him.
MarshaAugust 12, 2020
This is an exceptional article. The "social justice" movement as it exists today is highly destructive and not what many members of the church,who naively support it, believe it to be. Just look at the BLM movement (part of the "social justice" family). It's insisting on and teaching people they must acknowledge their "white privilege" which is teaching people there is something fundamentally wrong with their skin color. That is, by definition, racism.
MarenAugust 12, 2020
Thank you for putting into clear form the thoughts that have been percolating in my head and heart. Having moved through the era of Civil Rigjts in the ‘60’s, I find this new ideology one of very subtle tokenism. Thank you for your clarity. Your use of parallelism is beautifully written, by the way!
Nancy CavanaughAugust 11, 2020
I think some of the premise you define as social justice is a faulty narrative and does a disservice to a serious social issue that needs the support of Christians who believe that loving our neighbor is more than words.
Don SearleAugust 11, 2020
Excellent! Thank you, Rebecca.I plan to share this.
M. HomerAugust 11, 2020
Please read the whole statement from the BLM website regarding "families." They are opposed to the idea that a family unit be so rigidly defined, not that families should be dismantled. This statement is a simple way of saying everyone is part of our family and we will fight for everyone. From BLM: "We disrupt the Western-prescribed nuclear family structure requirement by supporting each other as extended families and “villages” that collectively care for one another, especially our children, to the degree that mothers, parents, and children are comfortable."
Michael Van WormerAugust 10, 2020
Outstanding article! Interestingly, the tactic of classifying people as the oppressed and the oppressors has been at the heart of Marxist ideology since its onset. It has been used to incite class warfare and to topple existing power structures. It is being used today by those that are ignorant of history and encouraged by those who have sought to implement their agenda for decades.
Daniel LarsonAugust 10, 2020
No mention of social justice in the Roman Catholic tradition. Perhaps some value may be found there. It’s a disservice to ignore other approaches to social justice if readers believe that this article covers the issue thoroughly.
AlysonAugust 10, 2020
Great article. I would be lost at this time without the gospel of Jesus Christ. I would be like the foolish man who built his house upon the sand, but instead, I I have the rock of the gospel of Jesus Christ and the prophets and apostles who are not blown by every wind of doctrine. I love the primary song, “Jesus said love everyone, treat them kindly too. When your heart is filled with love, others will love you.”
Merrill Van LeuvenAugust 10, 2020
Well written, well stated. These are my thoughts, just expressed so much more eloquently with experts weighing in. I appreciate this examination of critical social justice. Thank you!
Oliver NesbittAugust 10, 2020
A very positive and informative article, but not everyone is a member of the church and indeed knows nothing about the church. Where do we turn for social justice because we know not where to find it
TannerAugust 10, 2020
While this makes some good points regarding cancel culture and the importance of the family. I fundamentally disagree with the content and rhetoric of this article. I feel that it takes many points out of context and is misleading in its connections to the gospel. I don’t understand how striving to overcome a racist past as a society or a church is inconsistent with coming unto Christ. I believe Christ would stand up for the marginalized and would seek the fair treatment of others. This article has undertones of justification and rationalization. White members of the Chirch of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints are not the victims of the current social injustice at hand and we should not seek to justify our privilege. Again, just one mans opinion, thanks for sharing your thoughts.
Alyssum DunnAugust 10, 2020
Rebecca Taylor, you are spot on in what you have written about Social Justice Ideology. I don't think you need to be an "educated" person to understand what you have written. I have personal experience of how this ideology is man made, that it doesn't reflect how Heavenly Father feels and Jesus Christ feels about us and how we treat each other. It only creates more division than harmony. I try to share my experience and I am shut down when I do so. I appreciate you putting it into the perfect words to show how this ideology isn't in harmony with the Gospel of Jesus Christ!
Theodore BrandleyAugust 10, 2020
Social justice ideology is an integral philosophy of Marxism, which is the antithesis of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. Marxism is the foundation theory of Communism and its modern version called Progressivism.
Elsa DuboisAugust 10, 2020
I’ve held my tongue but this!!!!!! Thank you for unashamedly pointing out the truth. People accuse you if spoke up against the movement ( not the slogan!) for being unfeeling and unkind for expressing the same principles we’ve been taught using basic gospel doctrine in their attempt to steer and stress the very same principles but by using the pseudo subversive vernacular of the time. It really made me feel that the adversary’s power overcame people ever do subtly and deceivingly under this great cloak of pretense.And yes, as prophesied even the elect fell for it!!!!
Heather DubachAugust 10, 2020
I loved this article!
Becky BuxtonAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for this. I have objected to "social justice" because of the reasons you articulated, but I wasn't able to. Thank you for the research and facts.
Nerita Flake PetersonAugust 10, 2020
this was thoughtful, reasonable and logical. Thanks you so much.
Laura BeeymanAugust 10, 2020
Excellent! Thank you.
Aleisa EatonAugust 10, 2020
Wonderful article! Well researched, succinct and understandable.
Judith SmithAugust 10, 2020
Glenn Beck warned against social justice Y E A R S ago.
Carol AnnAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for an outstanding and strong voice of reason!
R BluthAugust 10, 2020
Very well written. Thank you for your content
David DurfeeAugust 10, 2020
Another view is that for the very first time in 2000 years we have a broad social movement that at its core (its core, mind you) is completely in synch with the Savior's Second Great Commandment. To me that feels inspiring. And maybe even inspired.
Robert StarlingAugust 10, 2020
While this article requires careful reading to gain its full impact, the author is spot-on with her analysis and comparison of this man-made ideology with the perfection of the Gospel of Jesus Christ. "Social Justice Warriors" amongst us are mis-informed and deluded by the "philosophies of men". As usual, the way to find truth is FTP - Follow The Prophet. And the truth will make us free.
ReedAugust 10, 2020
Exceptionally well researched and presented.
CarolineAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for this well-written and well-researched article. I’m saving it!
NanetteAugust 10, 2020
My question is why do only white people have to recognize racism? What about the Blacks addressing their racism against white people? Thank u for this wonderful article I know we needed.
PattieAugust 10, 2020
Thank you, thank you and thank you. I have been trying to make this statement to others but you have said it so well. Social Justice is only for the minority and is truly Satan led. I have contemplated the phrase “BlackLives Matter” , it is a racist phrase fueling the fire of hatred between races. The young lady who died because she said, All Lives Matter” didn’t have the opportunity to raise her son because of this racial phrase. She was ambushed and killed by men whose only thoughts were to destroy anyone who doesn’t think like us. What a great topic for you, you need to write a book on this very subject.
Cynthia PAugust 10, 2020
What an excellent, thorough treatment of this sensitive subject! I loved the sources you quoted - especially James Lindsay.
Lawrence M BarryAugust 10, 2020
Thank you for putting to words what I've been thinking and feeling about the social justice movement but was unable to understand until I read your article.
Kayleen HunsakerAugust 10, 2020
What a great article! It puts all the truth about this situation of "Social Justice Ideology" in a comprehensive and easily understood format. It helped me to understand why I was feeling so many "red flags" about everything going on-knowing it was not following Jesus Christ. Thank you for all your research and time to write this.
D. GoodwinAugust 10, 2020
I think this article was written for academics, and for the rest of the Meridian audiance, I thought it will be confusing and in some instances, misleading. Perhaps I just don't have the background in social psychology that I needed, but I was not convinced that I should be "concerned." To oppose an injustice (even through the lens of hindsight) is the same as condoning it, in my mind.
Heidi FeuzAugust 10, 2020
Great Article!
ADD A COMMENT