by Joseph L. Allen, Ph.D.
Editor’s Note: Joseph Allen is leading both land tours and cruises into the lands of the Book of Mormon for Meridian Trips. Come and explore an ancient world of jungles and pyramids. For more information click here.
This article is in response to the following question:
As a result of your research and travel what do you consider to be the most significant archaeological and historical evidence relating to the Book of Mormon? In other words, is there any credible evidence that can be used to determine where the Book of Mormon peoples lived?
Criteria
Before we can respond to the question of where the people of the Book of Mormon lived out their lives, we must first set parameters which will allow others to analyze the process of discovery and conclusions. For example, if we use the Book of Mormon as a control text we can arrive at several requirements for any comparative study with other ancient civilizations. These requirements include, 1) evidence of ancient civilizations of a magnitude of the Jaredites, Nephites and Lamanties, 2) linguistic and archaeological evidence, 3) parallel written records, cultural and agricultural similarities, and 4) similar or identical geographical patterns.
Two or three witnesses
With the above criteria in place, we are then in a position to test our hypothesis against two or three witnesses; AIn the mouth of two or three witnesses shall every word be established (2 Cor. 13:1). If I were talking to people not familiar with the Book of Mormon and who had a knowledge of the pre-Conquest history of Mexico, I would present the parallel accounts of the first settlers, or mother civilization of the Americas called the Olmecs, with the Jaredites.
Statement of hypothesis
Three separate, yet parallel accounts help to give us a fuller understanding of the mother civilization of the Americas. They are:
- The book of Ether and the account of the Jaredites.
- The archaeological record and the account of the Olmecs.
- The record of 16th century historian Fernando de Alva de Ixtlilxochitl and the account of the first settlers to Mexico.
I hereby propose that there is enough evidence to support a positive correlation between the above three mentioned records and the account of the first civilization of the Americas. Seven distinct parallels will be presented to justify this hypothesis.
Statement #1 THE FIRST CIVILIZATION OF THE AMERICAS
THE JAREDITE RECORD THE JAREDITE RECORD
Moroni, the son of Mormon, wrote an account of Athose ancient inhabitants.@ In other words, he wrote a brief history of the first civilization or mother civilization referred to in the Book of Mormon. They are called the Jaredites, named after their first king, Jared Moroni wrote his record between A.D. 385 and 421. It is reported that he obtained his information from records his father had given him, which records were recorded on 24 gold plates and discovered by the Limhi Expedition at 121 B.C. (Ether 1:1, 33; 5:1; Moro. 9:23-24; Mos. 8:7-9).
Joseph Smith, 1805-1844, through the power of God, translated the ancient record of the Book of Mormon from records which had been deposited in a hill near his home. The record includes a brief account of the first settlers called the Jaredites.
THE OLMEC RECORD
According to archaeological investigations from Mexico, the Olmecs are “the mother civilization of the Americas.” Their history is engraved on stones, and their remains have been discovered under mounds of dirt. The word Olmec means “rubber tree,” referring to the area where the ancient Olmecs had their heartland. An Olmec hieroglyphic text dating to 31 B.C. was discovered at the ancient site of Tres Zapotes in Veracruz, Mexico by Archaeologist Matthew Stirling and reported in a conference in Mexico on July 7, 1941. It was the discovery of this date that promulgated the theory that the Olmecs pre-dated the Maya and subsequently became known as the oldest civilization of the Americas dating from 1500-300 B.C. (See Exploring the Lands of the Book of Mormon, pp. 58-59)
Matthew Stirling, 1896-1975. Archaeologist with the Smithsonian Institute. He carried out archaeological excavations from 1938-46 at such important sites as Tres Zapotes, Cerro de las Mesas, La Venta and Izapa located in the Mexican states of Veracruz, Tabasco and Chiapas. Taken from 1998 Smithsonian Institution National Anthropological Archives. Photo copyright.
THE RECORD OF IXTLILXOCHITL
Don Fernando de Alva de Ixtlilxochitl was a mixture of Spanish and Toltec Indian royalty. He grew up in Texcoco, a suburb of Mexico City. He gained a great deal of fame as a court recorder and as author of “a history of the events in New Spain (Mexico),” which was written in Spanish and published in 1600. He referred to the oldest civilization as the first settlers to occupy the land of New Spain. He reported that he obtained his information about the first civilization of Mesoamerica from the ancient histories and from the oral traditions of the old people. (See the introduction of Ixtlilxochitl’s works in, Exploring the Lands of the Book of Mormon, Chapter 11, pp. 137-14, 1989 edition).
Fernando de Alva de Ixtlilxochitl, 1538-1650, wrote an ancient history of Mexico. His introductory work reports on the first settlers of Mexico. His works were first published in Spanish in A.D. 1600.
Two volumes of his works were republished in Spanish in 1892 by Alfredo Chavero. (Insert is of the cover page of vol. 2)
Summary and Conclusions on Statement #1: The First Civilization of the Americas.
The significance of the above correlation is centered on the two words, antiquity and civilization. The Jaredite nation dates from approximately 2800 -300 B.C. Both the archaeology of the Olmecs and the local history recorded by Ixtlilxochitl supports this time frame perspective. The concept of a “civilization” requires such things as language, centralized government, religious hierarchy, trade and commercial activity and warfare. A statement in Ether 10:18-28, written about 1000 B.C., sets forth the standardized requirement for any comparative study to follow. In subsequent articles evidence will be set forth demonstrating parallel statements of the Olmecs and the traditional history of Mexico with the statements recorded below.
Scripture reference:
Ether 10:18 – Kingships
Scripture summary:
Kish passed away and Lib reigned in his stead. Ether named 30 kings from Jared to Coriantumr.
Question of relativity:
Does the archaeological and traditional history support the concept of kingships? Are there any name correlations?
Scripture reference:
Ether 10:20 – Location
Scripture summary:
They built a great city by the narrow neck of land by the place where the sea divides the land.
Question of relativity:
Is their evidence of ancient cities dating to 1000 B.C. in a geographical area that meets the above description? In order for a society to be qualified as a civilization it must show evidence of large urban centers. Are there any geographical name correlations with what is recorded in the Book of Mormon?
Scripture reference:
Ether 10:21 – Commerce
Scripture summary:
They sold and “did” traffic one with another. This suggests an organized social structure which would require a centralized government with established laws.
Question of relativity:
What evidence exists in Mesoamerica of a society that is economically stratified?
Scripture reference:
Ether 10:22 – workforce activity
Scripture summary:
They worked all manner of ore, gold, silver, iron and copper and they cast up heaps of earth to conduct mining activities. Government control of mineral rights is a major aspect of a civilized society.
Question of relativity:
Is there evidence of the above mentioned activities in the area under investigation as the Jaredite homeland?
Scripture reference:
Ether 10:23 – Exports and industry
Scripture summary:
They had silks and fine-twined linen A civilized society is concerned about the physical needs of the people. Industry is controlled by government to provide work for the people and income to the government. This scripture may also suggest the importing of silk and a potential relationship with China.
Question of relativity:
Is there any correlative statements from archaeology and history that suggests a relationship with China and a centrally controlled workforce.
Scripture of reference:
Ether 10:24 – Agriculture welfare
Scripture summary:
They did make all manner of tools to till the earth, and they did reap and thrash. Effort is needed to make the tools and to till the earth. A function of a civilized society is to provide for the sustenance of the people.
Question of relativity:
What food products are grown in Mesoamerica that correlates with those mentioned in the Book of Mormon?
Scripture of reference:
Ether 10:24 – Military protection
Scripture summary:
They made all manner of weapons of war. A major purpose of a civilized society is to protect the people from harm.
Question of relativity:
What archaeological and historical evidence exists regarding warfare and the destruction of the nation by a civil war as outlined in the Book of Ether?
Scripture of reference:
Ether 10:28 – Religious principles
Scripture summary:
They were prospered by the hand of the Lord and they were in a land choice above all other lands. The Book of Ether is a religious record and speaks of prophets and preaching the gospel. It also speaks of Christ. Organized religion is an integral part of a civilized society.
Question of relativity:
Do the archaeological and historical records of Mesoamerica relating to the Jaredite time period justify the religious history and the worship of deity as contained in the Book of Mormon?
LDS archaeologist Bruce W. Warren records the following analogy regarding the criteria for a civilization and the relationship of Mesoamerica with the Book of Mormon.
“The society in the Book of Mormon meets the criteria of a civilization. By civilization is meant a society that is economically stratified, has large urban centers, and is involved in interstate relations. The Book of Mormon qualifies in all three domains. Only two areas of Ancient America developed to a civilization level before the coming of the Europeans. These two areas are Mesoamerica and the Andean area of South America. Neither Chile nor the northeastern part of the U.S. qualify as civilizations during the Book of Mormon time period and would therefore need to be discarded as potential Book of Mormon centers.
Mesoamerica has the surrounding sea as required by the Book of Mormon, elaborate writing systems as required by the Book of Mormon, and calendar systems dating back to the Book of Mormon time horizon. The Andean region does not meet these internal requirements from the Book of Mormon and is thereby eliminated as a potential setting for the Book of Mormon. Regarding the limitation of Book of Mormon lands, the text itself significantly limits the possible distance between cities and landmarks.
With reference to the third question, only recently have proponents of the Mesoamerica setting for the Book of Mormon begun to use the dimensions of historical or cultural geography in their study. Most of the need confirmation await future research for their discovery. However, based on available data regarding the Book of Mormon society, history, and geography, those scholars that place the book’s setting in Mesoamerica are on solid ground.” Article by Warren, Bruce W., Ancient America Foundation.
A civilization is also determined by length of existence and its population control. The Jaredites are numbered in the millions as reflected in Ether 15:2. Again the archaeological record and traditional history of Mexico supports the concept of a long and massive civilization. To put this in perspective, while there were people who lived in the north-eastern part of the United States and in some parts of South America during the Jaredite time period, evidence does not support these areas as identifiable as high civilizations.
In summary, we have pointed out the similarity of antiquity of the first settlers of the Americas and the need for a high civilization. This represents only one of seven comparisons of the Jaredites with the archaeological and traditional history of Mexico. Next time we will discuss in more detail some of the following.
Statement #2
The migratory route from the Tower of Babel to the Promised Land
Statement #3
The geographical location of the headquarters of the First Civilization
Statement #4
An analysis of the physical descriptions of the people
Statement #5
Customs, agriculture and migrations of the mother civilization
Statement #6
Warfare, kingships and the fall of the first civilization of the Americas
Statement #7
Religion and deity associated with the first civilization of the Americas
Advertisement
Look for Dr. Allen’s new book, Sacred Sites – Searching for Book of Mormon Lands, published by Covenant Recordings to be released in November 2003.
You may call 1-888-226-5205 for information on Book of Mormon Tours and Cruises
Lecture schedule of Dr. Joseph L. Allen at the Grove Theater in Pleasant Grove, Utah
September 30, 2003 Is the Book of Mormon a Hebrew or a Maya Document?
October 14, 2003 Where is the Book of Mormon Hill Ramah located?
November 25, 2003 What evidence is there about the ancient city of Nephi?
December 30, 2003 Teotihuacan, Tikal and the demise of the Nephite Civilization
SAVE $400 on your Sacred Site – Land of Nephi Tour. See www.ldstours.com and check on “featured tour” for details.